Montauk Yacht Club Hotel, Montauk ∞ Discover spa retreats, reviews & deals for 2025

Book with us and save

up to 10%

compared to Booking.com

Key details

About Resort

32 Star Island Road, Montauk, New York, United States of America, 11954

View all

Select your room type

The hotel offers a variety of rooms including double rooms, family rooms, and suites with breakfast, free cancelations, and special deals

Guest Room

Max:

4 persons

360 sq. feet

Bed options:

2 Double beds

Balcony

Air conditioning

room details

Check Prices

Villa

Max:

3 persons

360 sq. feet

Bed options:

1 King Size Bed

Heating

Air conditioning

room details

Check Prices

Deluxe Room

Max:

2 persons

360 sq. feet

Bed options:

2 Double beds

Sea view

Shower

Coffee machine

room details

Check Prices

Show all roomsLess

Price and Room Availability Calendar

Check availability and prices for your dates now!

Getting around

Explore a range of transportation options for your spa getaway

City Center

Montauk 2.5 mi

Airports

Long Island MacArthur (ISP) 69.7 mi

Tweed-New Haven (HVN) 107.4 mi

Facilities

The hotel offers amenities for your comfortable stay and unforgettable experiences

Delicious Dining!

“The Showfish restaurant served some of the finest culinary creations, including seared scallops that were simply divine.” view full review

Relaxing Fire Pit

“The outdoor fire pit area created a cozy ambiance, perfect for unwinding after a long day with comfortable seating and a beautiful atmosphere.” view full review

Stylish Room Decor

“The room featured a modern design with high-end finishes and a welcoming feel, making it a perfect retreat during our stay.” view full review

Well-Stocked Room

“Our room had a mini fridge filled with essentials, allowing us to have snacks and drinks readily available during our stay.” view full review

General

No smoking on site
Free Wi-Fi in public areas
Paid parking
Safe deposit box
24-hour reception
Pets allowed
Rooms/ Facilities for disabled
24-hour security
Baggage storage
Private beach
Allergy-free rooms
ATM/Cash machine
Coffee shop
Fireplace
Smoke detectors
Electric vehicle charging station
Fire extinguishers
Key card access
Key access

Sports & Fitness

Fitness center
Water sports
Hiking
Cycling
Tennis court
Golf course
Fishing

Services

Pet amenities available
Room service
Housekeeping
Laundry
Dry cleaning
Welcome drink

Dining

Restaurant
Snack bar
Bar/ Lounge area
Special diet menus

Business

Meeting/ Banquet facilities
Fax/Photocopying

Children

Children's pool

Spa & Leisure

Seasonal outdoor pool
Seasonal indoor pool
Beach access
Spa & wellness center

Room features

Air conditioning
Heating
Mini-bar
Sitting area
Patio
Terrace
Garden furniture
Tea and coffee facilities
Ironing facilities

Bathroom

Bathtub
Free toiletries

Media

Flat-screen TV
AM/FM alarm clock

Room decor

Carpeted floor

Location

32 Star Island Road, Montauk, New York, United States of America, 11954

Map view

32 Star Island Road, Montauk, New York, United States of America, 11954

City landmarks

50 S Fairview Ave

Montauk Downs State Park

1.4 mi

W Lake Dr

Gosman's Dock

1.3 mi

Golf Course

Montauk Downs State Park Golf Course

1.4 mi

Parks

Shadmoor State Park

2.1 mi

Farm

Rita's Stable

1.7 mi

Farm

Deep Hollow Ranch

2.1 mi

67 South Essex Street

Saint Therese of Lisieux Church

2.3 mi

18 Ditch Plains Rd

Ditch Plains Beach

2.2 mi

Parks

Fort Pond Bay Park

2.5 mi

Museums

Second House Museum

2.8 mi

Parks

Camp Hero State Park

2.5 mi

Store

Sunset Surf Shack

2.5 mi

Parks

Kirk Park Beach

2.8 mi

Montauk

Lake Montauk

2.8 mi

Fort Pond Bay

2.7 mi

1898 Montauk Hwy

Camp Hero

3.0 mi

Lighthouse

Montauk Point Lighthouse

4.0 mi

Nearby

Marina

Star Island Yacht Club and Marina

1200 ft

Restaurants

Star Island Grill

400 ft

Star Island Rd

Westlake Fish House

2700 ft

352 W Lake Dr

Swallow East Restaurant

1.2 mi

474 W Lake Dr

Grey Lady

4900 ft

440 W Lake Dr

Tiny Harbor Asian Cafe

4900 ft

440 W Lake Dr Unit B

The Dock

1.1 mi

482 West Lake Dr

Reviews and Ratings <br />

Feedback from previous guests about their experience.

74%

loved the resort and would return for another relaxing stay

Beautiful water view

Spacious room

Dining issues

Cleanliness concerns

7.4/10

Very good

Rooms

8.0

Location

7.4

Service

7.0

Dining

7.4

3.5/5 based on 80 reviews

#25 of 39 hotels in Montauk based on Tripadvisor

Jessica

United Kingdom, February 2025

7.4/10

Overall, this resort offers a beautiful setting and comfortable accommodations, which greatly enhanced our stay. The staff were attentive and friendly, contributing positively to our experience. However, the dining options could use improvement, particularly in their breakfast offerings, and certain behaviors regarding health protocols should be more strictly enforced.

Rooms

9.0

My room was beautifully designed with a nautical feel and had a stunning view of Lake Montauk, making for a delightful atmosphere.

Service

7.0

While most of the service was attentive, there were some lapses, especially in enforcing health guidelines, which left me concerned about the overall safety.

Location

8.0

The resort's location by the lake is lovely, but it can feel a bit crowded and noisy, especially during peak times.

Dining

5.0

The quality of the food was generally good, but breakfast was lackluster, with some aspects being inedible.

Facilities

8.0

The resort boasts wonderful amenities, including a lovely beach area and well-equipped gym, but some facilities could be better maintained.

Emma

United Kingdom, January 2025

7.0/10

I had a great stay overall, with the beautiful ambience and our spacious room being highlights. The attentive staff truly made a difference, especially during check-in. However, the dining experience left a bit to be desired, especially for breakfast, and I noticed some cleanliness issues in common areas. It was a lovely time, but improvements in dining would make it even better.

Rooms

8.0

Our room was quite large for a two double bedroom, featuring a beautiful water view and a spacious bathroom and walk-in closet. However, I encountered an issue with the key card lock not working properly and the wall needing some fresh paint.

Service

7.0

The staff was generally helpful and accommodating, and I felt they took pride in ensuring we had a pleasant stay. Yet, there were moments during my visit when service seemed a bit scattered, particularly during busy dining hours.

Location

8.0

The hotel is set in a tranquil area, giving you the perfect balance of peace while being not too far from local attractions. The marina view added a special charm, though some might find it a bit distant from the main beaches.

Dining

5.0

While I enjoyed some meals, breakfast was disappointing with not-so-fresh pastries and a lack of variety. I would have appreciated healthier and more appealing options to start the day.

Facilities

7.0

The facilities were nice overall, especially the pool area which was well-maintained. Although some areas needed tidying up, the indoor lounge was pleasant.

Beautiful water view

Dining issues

Michael

United Kingdom, October 2024

7.4/10

The resort offers beautiful marina views and has undergone renovations that improved the aesthetics, making the stay enjoyable overall. However, the mask policy enforcement needs attention, as my experience was marred by an uncomfortable situation involving another guest, which was not handled well by the staff. While the dining at Showfish was excellent, some service elements felt lacking, particularly around the pool area.

Rooms

8.0

We stayed in a waterfront room that was newly renovated and offered a lovely view of the beach. However, we noticed some noise from the hallway, which was a bit distracting.

Service

6.0

While many staff members were friendly and accommodating, I found that during certain incidents, such as enforcing the mask policy, the service was lacking.

Location

7.0

The resort is situated in a picturesque area by the marina, though the layout of the dining spaces felt cramped at times.

Dining

9.0

Dining at Showfish was fantastic, with fresh seafood and creative dishes. However, I would say it was a bit on the pricey side but worth it for quality.

Facilities

7.0

The resort had various amenities, including kayak rentals and nice outdoor spaces, but the poolside service could use improvement.

Sebastian

United Kingdom, October 2024

6.6/10

My stay at the resort was a mixed bag. The rooms were beautifully renovated and comfortable, and the dining at Showfish was excellent. However, I was very disappointed with the noise levels in the hotel, which made it hard to relax, and the service at check-in was frustrating. If they can improve the noise insulation and front desk responsiveness, it could be a great spot.

Rooms

7.0

The rooms have been beautifully renovated and are quite comfortable, but they have thin walls that let in a lot of noise from neighbors.

Service

5.0

Service at check-in was quite frustrating. The staff took a long time to respond to my inquiries, which added to the stress.

Location

6.0

The resort has a lovely beach area next to a lake, but the noise from nearby parties and club music was quite distracting.

Dining

9.0

Dining at Showfish was a highlight with fresh ingredients and creative dishes, definitely worth a visit during your stay.

Facilities

6.0

The pool area is nice, but it can get crowded quickly, especially with limited space.

Beautifully renovated rooms

Thin walls and noise

Matthew

United Kingdom, September 2024

8.6/10

My stay at Gurney’s Star Island was unforgettable. The stunning views of the marina paired with excellent service made it truly special. The rooms were spacious and well-designed, but the dining experience was a standout with fresh, delicious meals at Showfish. It felt luxurious overall, but I did wish for more variety in the recreational options.

Rooms

8.0

The room was spacious with a lovely balcony that had two comfortable chairs, although the design had some obstructions that blocked the view a bit.

Service

10.0

Service was exceptional, with staff like Maureen and Tim going out of their way to ensure we were taken care of during our stay.

Location

8.0

The property is beautifully situated by the marina, making it a serene escape. However, it can get crowded at peak times.

Dining

9.0

Dining at Showfish was a culinary delight with fresh seafood and creative dishes that elevated our meals to a new level. The atmosphere was lively and enjoyable.

Facilities

8.0

Facilities were top-notch with various activities available like kayaking and paddleboarding, but the beach area could be more accessible.